Home › Forums › Ask the Sensei › How to decide what fly line design to consider for nymphing

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #35813

      Sensei,

      What is your opinion on the appropriate leader/tippet design for the entry level fly fisher considering  nymph fishing in Missouri

      Background:  I am reading  Chouinard’s book (Pheasant Tail Simplicity) and he has 3 recommendations to attach to your fly line:

      1.  60′ monofilament with indicator line and 4-7 X tippet with dropper and point fly

      2.  Euro nymph fly line (.022″) with  10′ (0.010-0.015″ monofilament) with same dropper/point fly

      3.  2-3 wt. Fly Line with 4- 7 X monofilament tippet whose length is determined by water depth with same dropper/point fly.  Chouinard says the 5wt. line could work if necessary.

       

      or, from my perspective,  just tie a 6x tippet to a small weighted nymph with an elk hair caddis as the indicator…….

       

      Trying to keep my fishing as simple as I can….what am I missing?

       

    • #35830
      Sensei
      Participant

      John, my young grasshopper! Out of the country, I am as I write this. Forgive me, you must; until I return, a fuller answer must wait. Very effective, nymphing and Euro-style nymphing are, as we learned in Wisconsin during nymphing school. Many techniques there are—constantly changing, and challenging to master, they are. When from South America I return in November, more about the different techniques I will write. Perhaps a class or two, put together I will. Until then, patience, my young grasshopper!

       

    • #36079
      Sensei
      Participant

      Grasshopper John,

      Patient, you have been. Grateful, I am, that you waited until back in this great country of yours I returned. In a foreign land I was—foreign even to me, hmm. Returned now, I have, to answer your pressing question.

      Ever changing, the Euro Style Nymphing (ESN) game is. In the past four years alone, much have its techniques and strategies changed. Even for me, keeping up is difficult. An excellent question about leaders you ask, but one answer for every situation, there is not. In fly fishing, “it depends,” the answer often is. First, what you wish to accomplish, consider. Attend the next ESN school offered by Jason Randall and Jim Young’s Fly-Fishing School, I highly recommend. Until then, some light on your question, let us shed.

      Three types of leaders at least, choose from you may: a standard ESN leader, a thin ESN leader, and a micro-ESN leader. Guide your choice, your experience and expertise must. Harder to cast than the standard, the micro is. New to ESN, are you? With the standard leader begin, and on the ESN tension drift technique concentrate. Before the next lesson, this one learn, hmm.

      Standard

      Butt: 12-15 feet of 20-pound Maxima Chameleon
      Transition: 3 feet of 12-pound Sunset Amnesia
      Sighter: 18 inches of 0.013-inch Cortland Indicator Mono
      Tippet ring: 1, 2, or 3 mm tippet ring
      For up-and-across-stream presentations with an overhead tuck cast, excellent the standard Euro nymphing leader is. Very heavy nymphs, tandem rigs, light indicators, small streamers, and dry/dropper rigs, well it serves. More like fly line, it turns over. Stiffer and thicker it is, so more casting power for heavy or wind-resistant flies and tackle it provides. For the novice Euro nympher, the best starting choice this is: easiest to cast, mend, and control. But a trade-off there is. At distance, or with very light nymphs, more sag through the guides and beyond the tip-top you will find than with thinner leaders.

      Thin

      Butt: 12-15 feet of 10- or 15-pound Maxima Chameleon
      Transition: 3 feet of 10-pound Sunset Amnesia
      Sighter: 18 inches of 0.012-inch Cortland Indicator Mono
      Tippet ring: 1, 2, or 3 mm tippet ring
      Most versatile of these ESN leaders, the thin leader is. For up-and-across-stream presentations, use it you may. Farther across or downstream, where multiple current speeds you must cross, a good choice it remains. With a tuck cast, sidearm cast, or water-load cast, well it works.

      Lower to the water than the overhead tuck, the sidearm and water-load casts are. With these casts, the thinner leader helps you establish contact and control more easily. Lighter flies it can handle, yet enough power for tandem rigs, light yarn indicators, and micro-streamers it retains. Without disadvantages, it is not. Accustomed to casting fly line, are you? A little harder to cast, this leader will feel. And more than the micro leader, sag it will.

      Micro

      Butt: 12-15 feet of 5- or 6-pound Maxima Chameleon
      Transition: 3 feet of 5-pound Sunset Amnesia
      Sighter: 18 inches of 0.012-inch Cortland Indicator Mono
      Tippet ring: 1, 2, or 3 mm tippet ring
      Shallow water and light flies, the micro leader favors. With its light butt section, least of all it sags between the guides and beyond the tip-top. Across stream and across different current speeds, especially noticeable this becomes. Upstream tuck casts, sidearm casts, and water-load casts, all possible they are. Immediate contact and a dead drift you seek? The best tool for that task, the micro leader is.

      Specialized, however, the micro leader is: for Euro nymphing with only one or two lighter flies in water 10–36 inches deep. For heavy fly rigs, indicators, dry/dropper rigs, or streamer presentations, the best choice it is not. Most challenging to cast, it also is. An overhead tuck cast, perform you can, but practice you must. Energy well it does not transfer. Without proper line speed, more easily it falls. Patience, young angler.

      Yet still changing, the micro leader is. Now, one 30-foot piece of 4X–5X material to a tippet ring some use, with 6X–7X tippet below the ring. Confusing, yes—and constantly changing. Techniques that “float” the sighter, fish the Y angle, soak the fly, and more, we now have. Much to learn, there is.

      Slowly, begin we shall. On tension drifting the fly, first work. Then, to the other techniques graduate you may. Master everything at once, you need not. One good drift at a time, young Grasshopper.

       

    • #36282

      Sensei,

       

      Thank you for your ESN explanation.  Now to using the most appropriate rod…..

      Background….

      I have just completed building  a 9′ 5 wt. carbon fiber rod that is classifieds as a ‘fast rod’.

      Down to Montauk I went with my new rod….

      What I discovered:   it is not easy to cast with a ‘fast’ rod and a standard 9′ leader with a #18 or 20 nymph with a stiff wind and cold temps.

      The rod, and I,  performed better with wolly buggers later in the afternoon (or I became better at casting as the day warmed up!).

      If I am to embrace the ESN fly fishing, should I have considered a ‘softer’ rod, perhaps the 9′ or 10′

      3  wt. carbon fiber rod with the standard ESN rig you recommended……….

       

       

       

       

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.