Submitted by Jim Craig
What a perfect day! The kind of day you dream about all year. Clear skies, cool and comfortable temperatures, little wind, and magnificent fall colors throughout the woods. Then add plenty of fish in the river and a great group of guys to share it with!
Graduation trips for the guys in our fall fly-fishing class are beginning to ramp up. On Monday, November 16, 2026, Kenny Klimes and I had the pleasure of taking two of our newest members through their graduation experience at Montauk State Park.
I’m not sure who scheduled first, Jonathan Andrus or Orville Birdsong, but it really doesn’t matter. As so often happens in FATC, friendships develop quickly, and these two hit it off during the classroom sessions of our (awesome) fly-fishing class. Naturally, they wanted to share their graduation fishing trip, and it couldn’t have worked out any better. We had a blast!
For our graduation process, this is the day each student gets a one-on-one, on-the-water experience with a FATC instructor. On this day, we put our graduating students through a little good-natured razzing as they take everything they’ve learned during our four classroom sessions and casting class and put that knowledge into practice. After all, there’s a big difference between learning the technical aspects of fly fishing in a classroom and actually doing it on the water!
Jonathan and Orville were joined by eight other FATC members for this special occasion: Steve Darr, Steve Baker, Mike Harvey, Mike Bisaga, Dave Bargen, Bill Byington, Larry Mangels, and Bob Born, along with instructors Kenny Klimes and yours truly.
Once everyone was geared up, Kenny took Jonathan under his wing, while I paired up with Orville. We headed to our usual stretch of water just below the big boulder and above the dam to work on casting and practice the various techniques taught in FATC’s fly-fishing school. Both guys needed a little additional coaching on their casts, but they were soon getting the hang of it.
Jonathan’s Morning: A Little Bit of Everything
Kenny reports that once Jonathan got his casting dialed in, he was making some nice short casts and catching fish using all three techniques we teach: stripping a streamer, swinging a soft hackle, and dead-drifting a midge or nymph.
He did a nice job fighting the fish, although one big one managed to break him off. Lesson learned: Don’t try to “horse” a fish in!
Apparently, Kenny didn’t have to smack him on the back of the head even once for not following instructions (something that, according to urban legend, happens with Kenny’s students from time to time)!
Jonathan did manage to lose one fish while they were trying to get a picture, but Kenny captured a photo “just before the drop!” By lunchtime, Jonathan had landed at least five or six fish. Kenny even managed to have a little fun himself that morning, landing two fish while demonstrating the various techniques. It’s always nice when your demonstration goes all the way to the net!
Orville’s Morning: A Lesson in Hooksets!
Orville and I worked a stretch of river just downstream from Jonathan and Kenny. We had a somewhat more challenging morning.
Once Orville got his casting straightened out, we went to work on each of the techniques taught in our school. He was doing everything right, but we couldn’t get a single strike while stripping streamers or swinging soft hackles.
Orville seemed to be enjoying the experience and soaking up every bit of coaching I could offer. Meanwhile, I was getting a little nervous, to say the least. Lunch was just 15 minutes away, and we had exactly zero fish in the net. What kind of instructor was I, anyway?
Then we moved on to our third and final technique: dead-drifting a black zebra midge under an indicator.
Can you say COMEBACK?
Once I showed Orville how to zero in on the strike zone, things started happening. And that’s when the “true Orville” come out!
I had emphasized that he needed to be very quick with his hookset whenever the indicator moved, even slightly. Unfortunately, he apparently missed the part about it NOT being a violent hookset. After all, we’re fishing with some pretty delicate tippet!
Little did I realize that I was standing a little too close to Orville when he got his first opportunity. The indicator moved, and he responded with a take-no-prisoners, nuclear-powered hookset unlike anything I’ve ever seen. I couldn’t have been happier with his reaction time. Ninety percent of new fly fishers are way too slow on the hookset. But when he reared back on that rod, I honestly thought I was about to take the butt end of it right across my forehead!
After we both had a good laugh, I explained the finer points of a more tempered hookset. Orville jumped right back into the action. The problem? The “true Orville” was having a hard time dialing it down!
He was so excited every time the indicator moved that he kept delivering those overpowered hooksets, losing fish in the process. We both laughed because, no matter how hard he tried, he just couldn’t seem to help himself.
After several more violent hooksets and my repeated correction, I decided it was time to escalate the intensity of my corrective โcoaching.โ Following three more overpowered hooksets, I administered my first-ever (very gentle, purely for effect) slap to the back of his head for ignoring my repeated instructions and losing all those fish. IT WORKED!
Orville immediately got back into the action and managed to hook and land four fish in the final minutes before lunch. He was all smiles, and I was relieved that my reputation as a fly-fishing instructor remained intact!
A Great Afternoon on the Water
We all gathered for lunch at the picnic tables near the Naturalist’s Cabin. It was great to hear that just about everyone had enjoyed a productive morning. The sun had warmed things up nicely, and after refueling, everyone was ready to make the most of the afternoon before the 4:00 PM siren called an end to fishing.
As we do with all our graduates, Kenny and Jonathan headed up to the spring after lunch. By starting at the top and working our way downstream, we give our graduates an opportunity to see and experience most of the Fly Fishing Only area. They finished their afternoon swinging soft hackles through the riffles below the power lines.
Orville and I started our afternoon in those same riffles. Since he hadn’t managed to catch anything on a soft hackle that morning, that became our first priority.
It didn’t take long!
The long, dry summer and fall had significantly reduced the river’s flow, but once we got Orville’s fly into the right current and positioned it where the fish were feeding, he was on!
And guess what? That little bump I had administered to the back of his head earlier in the day had apparently made a lasting impression. His hookset had improved dramatically, and he was missing very few fish!
I think Orville would have been perfectly happy staying right there and catching fish all afternoon. However, I wanted to get him up to the spring so he could experience the rest of the Fly Fishing Only section of the river. Once we got there, we switched back to dead-drifting a Zebra Midge and stuck with that technique as we worked our way downstream until the 4:00 PM siren. He had a very successful afternoon.
Good Fishing, Great Fellowship
At the end of the day, we were greeted in the parking lot by plenty of smiles. Even those who had a challenging morning managed to get in on the action during the afternoon.
The fish seemed willing to cooperate with a variety of patterns. Olive woolly buggers, soft hackles, pheasant Tails, Griffith’s gnats, headlight caddis, elk hair caddis, and the good old quilldigon all seemed to do the trick.
We wrapped up the day with a fellowship dinner at Arandas, Kenny’s favorite Mexican restaurant in Salem, Missouri. It was a fitting end to a terrific day on the water.
As we’ve said many times before, men need time with other menโgood men. Our fishing trips provide a wonderful opportunity to build friendships, enjoy each other’s company, and strengthen the brotherhood that makes FATC special.
And remember, fishing is just one of the many ways to get involved. From fishing trips and educational opportunities to community service and charitable events, there are plenty of ways to connect with your FATC brothers.
Come join us! You won’t regret experiencing just how rejuvenating this kind of fellowship can be.
ONE MORE THING!
Don’t forget to join us for FATC MEMBERSHIP NIGHT at Dogwood Social House, 15682 Manchester Road, Ellisville, on Thursday, November 19, from 6:00โ9:00 PM.
I hear there will be beer drinking and axe throwing. What could possibly go wrong?!!












































