Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
December 15, 2025 at 8:07 am in reply to: FATC Days of Christmas (Day 2)…The Cast Heard Round Creation #33038
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantFATC Days of Christmas (Day 2)…The Cast Heard Round Creation
The gift that keeps on giving…this year, no partridges in pear trees or turtle doves; that’s for my Safari Club buddies. This gift is for my FATC buddies.
I’ve recently enjoyed reading Daniel Bryant’s book, GOD MUST BE A FLY FISHER, and I think many of you will enjoy it also. I’m reprinting a short chapter each day from now through New Year’s Day. This is not just a book about fly fishing. It’s a book about slowing down. It’s a book about seeing that every moment outdoors might be an invitation to come closer to the One who created it all.
(From God Must Be A Fly Fisher by author Daniel Bryant)
The Cast Heard Round Creation
In the beginning, God said, “Let there be light.” And I’d like to imagine that somewhere, just before those words were spoken, He false cast once or twice— just to get the rhythm right.
Because casting, like creation, requires precision, timing, and just a little bit of flair.
If you’ve ever watched a fly fisher work a perfect overhead cast, you’ve seen something more than muscle memory. It’s choreography. It’s intention. It’s the act of creation in miniature. You’re taking an invisible idea-a bug, a drift, a dream —and placing it exactly where it needs to land.
Kind of like how God shaped the heavens and the earth. With purpose. With grace. With a whole lot of patience.
Isaiah 40:26 says, “Lift up your eyes on high and see: who created these? He who brings out their host by number, calling them all by name.” You think threading a size 22 midge onto 6X tippet is tough? Try naming every star in the universe. That’s a level of detail even the best fly tier would tip their magnifying glasses to.
Fly casting has its own theology, really.
You learn quickly that power doesn’t come from brute force —it comes from finesse. The rod does the work. Your job is to feel the rhythm and trust the design. If you try to muscle it, you’ll tangle your line faster than a toddler with a box of spaghetti. But if you pause, if you let the rod load, if you lean into the timing —that line will sing.
And that’s just like God.
He doesn’t force His will. He guides it. With a steady hand.
With a quiet whisper. With a movement so smooth you almost don’t notice it —until the line unfurls like a ribbon of grace above the water.
And sometimes… it lands perfectly.
Other times? Well, let’s just say that tree wasn’t supposed to be part of the plan.
But God is patient —even when we’re not. Even when we blow the cast, spook the fish, or wrap our leader into an unholy mess of wind knots. He doesn’t give up. He waits. He mends. He casts again.
Sometimes I think prayer is like casting. We don’t always know where our requests will land. Sometimes we flail and flop and double haul our worries halfway to Canada. But God sees the intention. He reads the line. He knows the drift of our hearts.
So, when you’re standing in a river, casting toward a seam that looks just right, remember —you’re part of something older and holier than just fish and flies. You’re participating in a sacred rhythm. A creation story still being told.
And somewhere, I like to believe, the Lord smiles.
Because you’re casting just like He did —on the first day of everything.
And this is where faith enters.
You won’t always see the fish. The drift won’t always look perfect. The fly might disappear beneath the glare. But you cast anyway—not because you see —but because you trust. That’s the kind of faith Paul spoke about in 2 Corinthians 5:7: “For we walk by faith, not by sight.”
On the river, that might mean trusting your instincts, your experience, your guide, your training. But in life? It means trusting God’s hand even when you can’t trace His plan.
It means learning to pause. To breathe. To let the rod do the work. To believe that the One who set the stars in place also knows exactly where your next cast should land.
So cast again.
Not because you know where the fish are.
But because you know the One who made the river.
December 14, 2025 at 11:49 am in reply to: FATC Days of Christmas (Day1)…In the Beginning There Was A River #33033JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantFATC Days of Christmas (Day 1)… In the Beginning there was a River
Christmas is approaching and I have a gift for my FATC brothers. (No…it’s not a new Orvis Helios fly rod or even a package of Oros Strike Indicators.)
I’ve recently enjoyed reading Daniel Bryant’s book, GOD MUST BE A FLY FISHER, and I think many of you will enjoy it also. I’m reprinting a short chapter each day from now through New Year’s Day. This is not just a book about fly fishing. It’s a book about slowing down. It’s a book about seeing that every moment outdoors might be an invitation to come closer to the One who created it all.
(From God Must Be A Fly Fisher by author Daniel Bryant)
In the Beginning there was a River
If you’ve ever stood waist-deep in a cold mountain stream as the sun broke over the ridgeline and set the water sparkling like liquid fire, then you know —God was definitely onto something when He made rivers.
Genesis may not mention fly rods, 5X tippet, or blue-winged olives, but I’d be willing to bet the Garden of Eden had a trout stream running through it. Probably spring-fed. Definitely catch-and-release.
The book of Psalms says, “The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of His hands.” (Psalm 19:1). But for those of us who fish, I’d argue the rivers do too. Every riffle, every eddy, every perfectly placed cast that somehow lands just right—it all whispers something holy. Something eternal.
Fly fishing is not just about catching fish. In fact, sometimes it’s not about catching fish at all. It’s about slowing down long enough to see what God is doing in the details. It’s in the way the line arcs like a prayer through the air. It’s in the dance of a mayfly rising from the surface. It’s in the silence between the casts, when your heart syncs up with the current, and you remember—you’re not alone out here.
Let’s be honest. If God wanted to show off, He didn’t need the Grand Canyon. All He had to do was create a rainbow trout. Ever held one in the sunlight? That shimmering rose-colored stripe, those delicate black spots- it’s like He dipped His brush into heaven and said, “Let’s see them try to paint this.”
And have you noticed that some of the best people in the world can be found standing in rivers with funny-looking hats and too many tools hanging from their vests? They may not all quote Scripture, but many of them live it without knowing it. They practice patience. They live in hope. And they love their neighbor —especially the one downstream who keeps snagging branches and muttering under his breath.
I think God must smile every time someone wades into a river and forgets their troubles for a while. I think He stands back, arms crossed, nodding approvingly, saying, “That’s the way it’s supposed to be.”
So welcome to this book —a celebration of fly fishing, yes, but more than that, a celebration of God’s glory revealed through water, creation, and the quiet pull of the line. Along the way, I’ll share some stories, laugh a little, dig into the Word, and maybe even hook into something deeper than we expected.
Because out here, among the rocks and willows, under the watchful eyes of eagles and elk, you begin to understand something profound:
God must be a fly fisher.
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantFATC Days of Christmas… GOD MUST BE A FLY FISHER
Christmas is approaching and I have a gift for my FATC brothers. (No…it’s not a new Orvis Helios fly rod or even a package of Oros Strike Indicators.)
I’ve recently enjoyed reading Daniel Bryant’s book, GOD MUST BE A FLY FISHER, and I think many of you will enjoy it also. I’m reprinting a short chapter each day from now through New Year’s Day. This is not just a book about fly fishing. It’s a book about slowing down. It’s a book about seeing that every moment outdoors might be an invitation to come closer to the One who created it all.
(Preface for God Must Be A Fly Fisher by author Daniel Bryant)
Why I Wrote This Book
I didn’t set out to write a book about God.
I set out to write about fly fishing –the sport that has shaped much of my life, refined my patience, and brought me closer to creation than almost anything else ever has.
But the more I wrote, the more I realized…
You can’t separate one from the other.
Not for me.
Not anymore.
Because somewhere between the cast and the current, I began to see it clearly:
God must be a fly fisher.
Who else could craft a world so delicate, so intricate, so wildly beautiful and yet so perfectly balanced?
Who else could teach through water, through wilderness, through the quiet rise of a trout under a pale blue sky?
Who else could speak through storms —and also through stillness?
This book is a collection of stories some pulled from Scripture, some from my own life, many from long days on the water where heaven felt a little closer. It’s written for believers, doubters, wanderers, and weary souls alike. It’s for anyone who’s ever stood in a river and wondered if there’s more to life than what they’ve seen.
Maybe you’ve never held a fly rod. That’s okay.
Maybe you’ve never opened a Bible. That’s okay too.
This book isn’t about doctrine or dogma.
It’s about invitation.
To slow down.
To look around.
To listen.
And maybe —to believe.
Because whether you’re casting a dry fly in the golden light of evening or casting your cares before the Lord, I believe the One who made the river still walks its banks.
And I believe He’s calling each of us to wade in.
— Daniel Bryant (Author of God Must Be A Fly Fisher)
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantScott, My Dear Friend:
Your’s was the best trip report I’ve ever read. I too give thanks to God for answering our many prayers for your survival and recovery.
I also feel it says a lot about you to share your experiences, your thankfulness and your health-related tips on the FATC FORUM with all your FATC brothers. Oftentimes, we are quick to ask for prayers and help from God, but then not take the time to give thanks.
Get well soon. We miss you at the FATC Wild at Heart Book Study, as well as, at the Legacy Builders’ weekly Bible Study.
I’ll continue to pray for the health of your heart –and the health of your soul.
John Muckerman
FATC Inspirational and Leadership Studies Lead
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantA few days ago, I shared some thoughts on significance verses success. It may have just been one of the many messages you were bombarded with during a fast paced day. Then again, for some of you it may have gotten you thinking about how you are investing your life. There is a brevity to life –and as we get older, the days seem to go by even more rapidly.
Maybe this desire for significance and to invest in things that really matter has taken root in your heart, but the fear of failing and the busyness of life is choking it out. We are each masters at looking the other way, procrastinating, talking ourselves out challenges. Some of us just settle for less, some of us fear the unknown –but fear is a liar!
Here are quotes from two famous and inspirational men. Perhaps they will talk to you–maybe even motivate you to move forward out of your comfort zone and to take action:
Mark Twain said: “Life is short, break the rules, forgive quickly, kiss slowly, love truly, laugh uncontrollably and never regret anything that made you smile. Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things you didn’t do than by the ones you did. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover.”
Teddy Roosevelt said: “It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and tears; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory or defeat.”
Your thoughts?
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantKenny,
I waited a few days after you posted the excerpt from John Eldridge’s Wild at Heart Daily Devotional to see if you would get any replies. Eldredge asks, “Are men becoming just Nice Guys? Are our churches turning us into ‘nice guys’”?
You asked, “What do you think?” I can’t wait any longer to reply—even though I realize many guys may have read it and are thinking about it—and that’s nice. Or maybe many guys won’t reply because, after all, it’s not nice to talk about “religion”. It’s not politically correct—and isn’t that how many men and many churches measure nice?
It’s as if some of these same men and churches believe that Jesus became man, suffered, died and was buried just to show us how to be nice guys—even though Jesus said he came to seek and save the lost.
Of course, this begs the question, “Do we get to heaven by being nice?” And that begs the question, “Then how nice is nice enough or good enough?” Then that should beg the question, “Why did Jesus come to seek and save the lost, if being nice or good enough was the ticket to salvation?”
As I read the Bible, I get the idea that Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross was the payment for the sin debt of those who trust in him as Savior and Lord. And since Jesus was born without sin and lived a perfect life I get the idea it was the only acceptable sacrifice to God.
Oh, I run into some nice guys that say they don’t sin—at least not serious sins. I wonder if they have read in Matthew 5 where Jesus basically says if you think an ugly thought about another person or call another a fool it’s worthy of hell.
I was wondering if maybe this nice guy goal that some men have is because they are still going on what they think they heard in second grade. Maybe it’s time to start reading the Bible seriously with adult eyes and an adult mind.
And maybe, just maybe, some churches are perpetuating the goal because it preaches well and doesn’t make waves. In other words, it’s good marketing and good marketing (they think) equates to more butts in pews on Sunday.
By the way, by most men’s definition of nice, I don’t think Jesus (who is my Savior and Lord) was a nice guy. Nice guys don’t call their religious leaders “blind guides”, “offspring of vipers”, “hypocrites” and “white washed tombs”.
Once, when Jesus entered a temple and found money-grubbing marketers selling animals inside, he “made a whip out of cords, scattered their coins, and overturned their tables,” yelling at them, “How dare you turn my Father’s house into a market” (John 2)! Hmmmmm, that’s just not nice!
Nice guys usually aren’t hated, betrayed, flogged, mocked, and crucified. But Jesus experienced all five. Why? Because Jesus wasn’t nice. Jesus wasn’t nice, he was kind. There’s a big difference; they are not one in the same.
Apparently the Apostles weren’t nice guys either. All of them were hunted down, tortured and martyred except John who was exiled to an island where he eventually died.
So what’s wrong with being a nice guy? It’s only when you stop caring about a being nice that you can really find what your made of, and what matters to God in this short life you’ve been given.
Jesus was a man on a mission and he wants us to participate with him in that mission. The resurrected Jesus told his followers: “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:18-20).
That Great Commission that Jesus commanded us to do is a loving, kind, obedient, kingdom-building, way of life—but it’s not a popular, nice thing to do in this woke, politically correct, humanistic world. And it’s not talked about much in many churches.
Nice—where’s the passion in nice? What kind of a mission would that be. And it’s becoming more obvious all the time that everybody measures nice differently. What a mess! How sadly ego-centric can you get verses God-centric!
I was wondering if John Eldridge is insinuating that the bar is so low on just being nice that it becomes synonymous with dull, boring, apathetic, half-hearted, lukewarm men.
Jesus used some pretty harsh words to describe his feelings regarding lukewarm Christians when he was addressing the church in Laodicea: “So, because you are lukewarm, and neither hot nor cold, I will vomit you out of my mouth” (Revelations 3:16).
Well, after reading my reply, you can surmise that I’m not a very nice guy, but that’s ok. If my words help wake up even one guy who reads them, I’m ecstatic. If even one guy decides to get more serious about his faith and seek a life of real significance, I’m happy. In fact, I’m just happy I said them.
Kenny, I too care less and less about what people say about me—but I too (as you stated in an earlier post) am praying for the day when Jesus might say to me, “Well done, good and faithful servant.”
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantWell, FATC brothers, what do you think about that? Yesterday, I was telling Chuck how much I treasured my involvement in FATC. You might say I was trying to express the FATC ethos to him. I suggested he check out our robust website–because, as they say, “a picture is worth a thousand words.” Considering that the website has a thousand photos, many of which are snapshots of true fellowship; our website must be worth at least a million words.
Because of the kind of friend Chuck is, he actually took the time to check it out, and to my amazement to say something really nice about me. Chuck might not know much about fly fishing, but he sure knows how to be a friend. He’s a much better friend than I deserve. In fact, he’s a world class friend! And Chuck is not afraid to talk about love for Christ–that takes a real man! I plan to buy Chuck a membership in FATC. We can always use members with that kind of character–even if they call a strike indicator a bobber and don’t know how to mend.
I was wondering, how are you at expressing to your family and friends your love or friendship for them? It really feels good to be on the receiving end of compliments. Chuck’s unexpected, short comment brought tears of joy to me. Moreover, it has provided me motivation to do the same for family and friends. Chuck made my day and I realize I could easily do the same for others.
In fact, as I ruminated on Chuck’s kindness and his self-initiated expression of friendship, another thought came to mind. It’s a somber thought, but a pragmatic, fact-of-life type of thought. How do I know that the last time I see a friend, it’s not the last time I see that friend?
-
This reply was modified 4 years ago by
JOHN MUCKERMAN.
JOHN MUCKERMAN
ParticipantI think Sensei had some very wise things to say about brotherhood, growth and the power of small group studies. I know I have been very blessed by participating in the small group studies.
In fact, Sensei’s comments reminded me of a quote that legendary coach, John Wooden once used: “You will be the same person in five years as you are today except for the people you meet and the books you read.”
It’s wise to ask yourself, what am I reading (besides some magazines) and what am I doing to meet and get to better know other guys?
BTW…Here’s another apropos John Wooden quote, “Learn as if you were going to live forever, and live as if you were going to die tomorrow.”
-
This reply was modified 4 years ago by
-
AuthorPosts
